Watch Linwood Mining and Minerals put John Deere L-Series production-class wheel loaders through their paces in a quarry.
How to maximize cone crusher performance
When operations truly maximize cone crusher performance, the payback includes lower cost per ton, greater plant uptime, increased production of highly saleable material and reduced maintenance and wear costs
Every producer wants peak crushing performance but not every producer knows how to achieve it. Getting there may require just a few tweaks or a total rebuild, while remaining at peak levels requires proactive maintenance practices, combined with expert consultation and continuing education, according to Mike Schultz. As crushing product manager for Superior Industries, Schultz brings more than two decades of crushing industry experience to their team of product, parts and service professionals.
"Maximum cone crushing performance requires a complete understanding of the application parameters, the design limitations of the crushing machine and the processing circuitry needed to support that machine," he emphasizes.
A cone crusher uses compression to effectively crush abrasive material, as well as a wide variety of stone from medium to very hard compressive strength. It is a versatile machine that can be used in all phases of material reduction, from the rock face to product finishing but more often than not its duties are targeted to secondary, tertiary and quaternary aggregate and mining applications.
Schultz explains that from a bottom-line standpoint, to maximize performance and cut wear costs means you need to get every stone through a cone crusher that you safely can, while preventing any machine damage, and still meet or exceed production goals.
Solutions and strategies to maximize cone crusher performance
Whether specifying a new machine or fine-tuning an existing crushing circuit, all key parameters must be defined upfront, Schultz says, and that means defining the work that you want that crusher to do. To do this, operations must provide data on proper feed gradation, desired output gradation, tonnage requirements and, most importantly, the material type. In addition, knowing the precise composition, compressive strength (maximum force that material can withstand before breaking) and chemical properties of the stone is a huge factor in determining how much work a cone crusher needs to do.
"Many operations try to do too much with one machine, pushing it beyond its design limitations, causing excessive component stress and wear and the potential of serious damage," Schultz says.
All crushers are designed for certain reduction ratio limitations. In most cases, cone crushers provide reduction ratios (the ratio of the feed size to the crusher vs. the size of the crusher discharge) of 4-to-1 up to 6-to-1. "The reduction ratio design limitations and the rated capacity (tons per hour) of the cone crusher are the most important factors to consider when designing a crushing circuit – and determining how much that crusher can safely do," Schultz says.
Once complete application data is in hand, it's important for operations to work closely with their crusher supplier to select the right crusher. Key considerations will be crushing speed, chamber design, liner configurations and crusher settings.
"Whether it's minimizing fines or maximizing fines, or trying to create the highest yield of a particular product, there are chamber and liner configurations designed specifically to meet the desired product yield," says Schultz.
Designing the right circuitry
For performance efficiencies, proper circuitry should be designed around the cone, says Schultz. Importantly, the circuit should be engineered to provide the cone with choke-fed material, or enough material to keep the crusher full. Having too little feed can cause the machine to side load, which stresses components. Also, having too many fines in the feed leads to premature wear issues.
Having adequate screening capacity downstream of the crushing circuit is another key factor. In a closed-circuit setup, material that is not properly sized is recirculated back to the crusher for further reduction.
"It's very common to see operations that have a bottleneck at the screening circuit. They do not have enough screening capacity, so properly crushed material is sent back to the cone. These unnecessary recirculating loads simply eat up more space and horsepower in the crusher while increasing wear," says Schultz.
Make use of automation
"To significantly affect cone performance, automation doesn't need to be over-the-top and super complicated, but rather quite simple and very easy to control," Schultz emphasizes. One of the biggest things that automation delivers is protecting the machine from damage by acting as a warning system that alerts operators to conditions such as bowl float, excessive amperage or temperatures, and lubrication or low-flow oil issues.
As an example, he points out that Superior's Patriot Cone series features a three-sensor "bowl float" or "ring bounce" monitoring system that alerts the operator if conditions are overexceeding the design limitations of the cone. The top and the bottom of the cone are held together by hydraulic cylinders.
When the crushing action on the cone exceeds the pressure that is holding those two pieces together, it causes bowl float or ring bounce, which is any movement at all (even slight) between the top and the bottom of the crusher, Schultz explains. Undetected bowl float will eventually lead to component failures. "When operating a cone, preventing bowl float is arguably the single most important thing you should ensure."
Most cone crushers are designed to open up due to tramp metal or an uncrushable situation. However, no cone crushers are designed to operate under normal conditions with ring bounce.
"There should be zero ring bounce or bowl float under normal operating conditions," says Schultz. "Without an automation package, it can be difficult to detect ring bounce at times. You can literally be standing on the machine, and you cannot detect even the slightest ring bounce – so having that automated warning system is an enormous advantage."
Know the true limiting factors
One of the major misconceptions Schultz encounters in the field is the way operators view the closed-side setting (the material discharge opening from maximum to minimum) of the cone. He says that operators often try to maintain a specified closed-side setting, assuming that will yield the desired product output no matter what. Often, they close the setting down to the smallest point possible and then let the machine beat itself up.
Schultz suggests a better approach to setting up a cone for maximum performance.
First, consider the true limiting factors of any cone crusher are attached power and crushing force.
After determining the proper speed and liner configuration, it is possible to dial in the proper settings of the machine based on maximizing the amp draw to a desired set-point, while making sure that the machine does not incur ring bounce at that point.
He also encourages operations to tie an automated warning system into the designed amperage utilization of the machine. With Superior's automation package, "if the motor and the machine are being overworked, the system will either take steps to reduce the amp draw, or will send an alarm to the operator," he explains.
Automation features are designed to maximize the life of wear components.
Patriot Cone's auto-wear compensation, included in the automation package, is an example. As liners begin to wear, the crusher is designed to automatically compensate for that wear in order to maintain the same settings in the machine. With liner wear, the space between the two compression components expands. At the same time, the auto wear compensation system automatically closes the machine down to maintain proper settings throughout the life of the wear components.
More from Aggregates & Quarries
MAJOR, a manufacturer of high-performance screening media, introduces the Flex-Mat Sensor, a valuable and easy to operate vibration data measurement tool users can utilize to review results and fine tune their screen machine without shutting down the equipment. The app-controlled vibration analysis sensor enables readings of screen box vibrations within seconds and generates a report that can be sent or reviewed. The simplicity of the system's design ensures valuable and actionable data without the requirement for a plant shutdown to calibrate the sensor.
Superior Industries Inc. has announced that a limited lifetime warranty now comes standard with new Patriot Cone Crushers. One-of-a-kind in dry bulk crushing, the no cost extended warranty covers the cone's major components including the adjustment ring, bowl, eccentric, head, mainframe and main shaft.
EvoQuip and Emerald Equipment will host an open event in New Jersey on July 25-26, 2019. This exclusive event will showcase live working demos of the company's Bison 280, Cobra 230 and 230R as well as the entire Colt range.
Continuous expansion, high quality standards as well as short delivery deadlines made such a step necessary for the manufacturer of mobile crushing and screening machinery, Kormann Rockster Recycler GmbH from Ennsdorf. The acquisition of a 10,000 m² property in Neumarkt im Mühlkreis (Upper Austria) promises to provide a strong and needed force in a continuous growth and market demand.
As the general manager of aggregate equipment manufacturer McLanahan, Mark Krause has seen a lot of change in the industry as a whole. Advances in technology are making significant inroads into aggregates, and that, combined with desire for more mobility from customers and a drive to draw new, younger professionals to the industry is what Krause sees shaping the market in coming years.
For Wayne Ylitalo, relationships with suppliers and customers is everything. That is how he built his business. Following that core principle has led him to a successful lifelong career in the aggregate industry around Toronto and across Ontario. It's also why he's been using VEI loader scales from RMT Equipment for 20 years. "When you buy something good, you have to tell other people how good it is," he says.
Metso has signed an agreement to acquire McCloskey International, a Canadian mobile crushing and screening equipment manufacturer, to expand Metso's offering in the aggregates industry globally and to strengthen the customer reach especially to general contractor customers.
Haver & Boecker Niagara offers rugged primary crushing plants in a wide variety of configurations for pre-crushing, secondary and tertiary crushing in the mining and aggregates industries. From design to installation, the manufacturer uses its extensive industry experience and knowledge to provide turnkey systems engineered and built to individual specifications. Haver & Boecker Niagara will work with any crusher and peripheral component manufacturers to ensure customers receive the best plant matched to their requirements.
Metso has reached the significant milestone of 10,000 Nordberg® HP cone crushers sold globally. The most popular modern cone crusher in the world, according to Metso, the HP Series celebrates its 30th anniversary this year. The 10,000th HP cone crusher unit was handed over to the French aggregates and asphalt producer and urban infrastructure development company Eurovia in a ceremony held this week at Metso's Mâcon facility in France.
Cedarapids, a Terex Minerals Processing Systems (MPS) brand, offers a new range of cone crushers. The new TG Series will be a Bronze Bushing Spider Bearing Cone. This new series of cones will complement the current Cedarapids MVPX Series (Screw Type Cone) and the Cedarapids TC Series (Floating Bowl Cone). Terex MPS will now offer a solution for every cone crushing application requirement while meeting the application needs of customers with the best possible product quality and productivity.
Lindsey Aggregates, based in New York state, is to open its doors this June to showcase its new multi-million-dollar integrated sand washing system, designed and installed by full-service EPC company CDE.
Impact crushers have broad appeal across various sectors and for good reasons. Our panel of experts provides insight as to why this is, plus information on the dynamic market for impact crushers in Canada, their applications and advantages, customization and options, as well as what to consider when buying an impact crusher.
Following Terex Corporation's release of its first quarter 2019 results, Terex Materials Processing (MP) is pleased to share these, along with its segment-specific results.
Modern crushing plants have become more and more complex as their requirements rise. At the same time, the technology must be safe and as simple as possible to operate – and without lengthy instruction and familiarization periods. This is the challenge which faced Kleemann. At bauma 2019 Kleemann showcased innovative solutions for the safe and simple operation of crushing and screening plants.
Haver & Boecker has established its global brand Haver & Boecker Niagara to combine the engineering expertise and product portfolios of its three mineral processing locations in Brazil, Canada and Germany. In the past, the three locations acted individually for their respective regions and territories. Customers around the world will benefit from shared innovative technology, more in-depth consultations, greater parts availability and better delivery times.
At Bauma 2019, Rockster not only presented its diverse range of products, but also immersed the visitors in new fields of interest. Wolfgang Kormann, CEO of Rockster Recycler from Austria, is convinced that this trade fair really deserves to be called "The World's Leading Trade Fair for Construction Machinery".
Lake Erie Portable Screeners introduces the heavy-duty Pitbull PB678 Static Grizzly. The compact screen is a smaller version of the popular PB148 for added jobsite versatility and pairs well with the Pitbull 2300 screening plant, making it an economical option for operations looking for a compact solution to sort oversize material on a reduced scale. The PB678 Static Grizzly includes features for easy bar removal or adjustments as well as transportability. It is ideal for a wide range of industries, including aggregates, mining, scrap, excavation, demolition, forestry and landscaping.
Washing equipment specialist McCloskey Washing Systems (MWS), along with their UK dealer MaxInnovate Ltd, held its first multi-spread demonstration event, at Monk Plant Hire (MPH) in Hockering, Norwich, UK on Wednesday 20th and Thursday 21st March, highlighting the power of the washing equipment working together. The demonstrations were an integral part of events tailored to familiarize both new and established dealers and customers with the versatility and productivity of MWS latest products.
Aggregates equipment OEM Metso began a partnership with Volvo Penta in 2016 following increased customer demand for fuel-efficient engines. Now, it is set to install Volvo Penta's Stage V solutions as an option on its mobile crushing machines.
Terex Finlay showcased the latest addition to their 8-Series line up of heavy duty screeners, the ‘883+ triple shaft' at Bauma 2019. This new model has been developed specifically to work in a variety of dry and difficult sticky applications including quarry, mining, sand and gravel, construction and demolition debris and recycling applications.
"Hauling is one of the most cost-intensive components of a typical mining or quarrying operation. In addition to fuel and labor, there's plenty of maintenance involved too. To ensure cost efficiency, a haul truck should carry as much payload as possible on every round. At Metso, we set out to tackle this challenge and designed a truck body that requires minimal maintenance while maximizing payload. The result is a lower operating cost per hauled ton," says Lars Skoog, Vice President, Mining Wear Lining & Screening, Metso.
Keestrack prides itself in consistently developing its worldwide manufacturing capacities. The company, which at bauma celebrated its 10,000th production machine since the legendary "4518" was introduced in 1996, is also marking the completion of its new 8740-square-metre assembly complex, the second extension phase of its main factory in Šternberk, Czech Republic. More milestones and new extension projects will be set and started in 2019, including the opening of Keestrack's Indian assembly in Neemrana and new production capacities in Ponzano Veneto, Italy.
Powerscreen showcased its revolutionary OMNI by Terex technology to help improve jobsite safety and efficiency in operating Powerscreen equipment at the recent bauma 2019.
Metso is introducing the latest addition to the versatile MX Multi-Action cone crusher series at Bauma 2019. The MX3 enables improved crusher productivity and lower operating costs with a design optimized especially for mid-sized quarrying.
The second generation J-1160 jaw crusher has been designed with the customer and operator in mind. In comparison to its predecessor the plant has a number of improvements such as increased under jaw clearance and all round preventative maintenance and serviceability access.
CDE has launched the Combo™ in a move set to revolutionize the wet processing industry.
Terex Minerals Processing Systems (MPS) has launched a new series of Simplicity Standard Incline (SI) screens designed for heavy duty, medium and fine screening applications and come with many features which make the screens more versatile and highly reliable in the market.
Aggregates operators are always looking for ways to improve their efficiency and make more informed decisions in their planning processes. Many are adopting emerging technology as an added way to develop their operations, and the advent of drones is playing a large part.
Volvo Construction Equipment's Electric Site project aims to test the world's first "emission-free" quarry by electrifying each transport stage, from excavation to primary crushing, and transport to secondary crushing. It uses both electric and autonomous Volvo CE prototype machines, plus new machine and fleet control systems and an entirely integrated real-time site management system. Together, these form a complete Electric Site solution. Volvo CE and its customer Skanska tested the viability of the Electric Site research project for 10 weeks at a Skanska's Vikan Kross quarry near Gothenburg, Sweden. Heavy Equipment Guide staff were on site to see the operation and learn about the results.
At this year's bauma, Kleemann presents a comprehensive cross-section of its innovative product portfolio with a total of seven mobile crushing and screening plants. High-performance machines and environmentally-compatible solutions for natural stone and recycling applications will be presented.
It is no surprise that there are plenty of variables that come into play when it comes to optimizing an aggregates operation. One area in particular where telematics and other technologies can improve efficiency and profitability is tracking and managing loadout activities.
Keestrack offers today the most versatile range of hybrid and plug-in solutions in mobile processing technology for quarrying and recycling applications. This applies to the complete product range, from screening plants and stockpile conveyors to mobile track-mounted crushing solutions of all relevant technologies and for all production capacities.
Terex Washing Systems (TWS) will present live washing demos of their game-changing AggWash 60 during bauma 2019. This showcase, in conjunction with their German distributors Kolsch and Christophel, is being hosted at Mittermeier (Kolsch customer site), located next to Hall FN 1024 / 1, April 8-14, 2019.
At the start of 2019, Kleemann was awarded two international design prizes: the iF DESIGN AWARD and the GOOD DESIGN Award for the jaw crusher MOBICAT MC 120 Z PRO and the screening plants of the EVO line. Innovative details for safe operation and simple handling impressed the jury members.