Heavy Equipment Guide Logo

Using recycled aggregates for roadbuilding is the way of the future – time for many to catch up

On the path to building sustainable roads

Recycling concrete and asphalt from roadways keeps the material out of landfills and is a green alternative to using virgin aggregates for new roads.
Recycling concrete and asphalt from roadways keeps the material out of landfills and is a green alternative to using virgin aggregates for new roads.

Municipalities are responsible for the care and maintenance of vast amounts of roadway, from alleys to highways. When those roads are repaired or replaced, there's the potential to generate a significant amount of aggregate material - concrete and asphalt removed from the old surface that must be dealt with.

Today's roadbuilding contractors are using this recovered material and recycling it more than ever before. However, research is showing that some municipalities in Ontario are far better than others when it comes to using recycled aggregate in their roads - and some are far behind.

A study conducted on behalf of the Toronto and Area Road Builders Association (TARBA) has shown that Ontario municipalities are all over the map with respect to how much recycled material they use for road construction, with some almost entirely eschewing recycled aggregate - a greener alternative compared to virgin material - for their projects.

"There's not a huge commitment to recycling aggregate; in fact, there's a reticence to use the product," explained Rob Bradford, executive director of TARBA. "I think it stems from a fear of trying something new, thinking that something might happen - sticking with virgin aggregate has less potential for risk."

According to a study by a researcher from the University of Western Ontario, the allowable use of recycled aggregate across the region ranges from significant amounts in some large areas like Toronto, down to nearly none in nearby Mississauga. Instead, according to Bradford, millions of tonnes of material is either sent to the landfill or into stockpiles. At the same time, those low rates of use mean that new aggregate must be trucked significant distances, burning fuel and generating greenhouse gases, while used aggregate ends up in the waste stream. 

Recycled aggregate means more sustainable infrastructure, overall, and Ontario municipalities should be doing a much better job - a much greener job - of recycling asphalt and concrete, Bradford noted. "They need to be a part of the solution, rather than part of the problem." 

TARBA is encouraging municipalities to find ways of using more recycled asphalt in their construction work. Shown here a Metso crushing plant processing aggregate materials.

Focus on construction practices
The UWO study looked at construction practices in five regional municipalities and 15 single or lower-tier municipalities across Ontario, conducting a survey regarding approved uses of recycled aggregate for use in a variety of situations. Results of the survey showed a broad range of standards in both road construction and subdivision work. 

For example, the collected responses showed that some 50 percent of surveyed municipalities do not allow the use of recycled concrete and asphalt as 55 mm aggregate for granular base and subbase for pavement. 40 percent allow partial use and 10 percent allow for full use. The municipalities are even more restrictive when it comes to 19 mm aggregate for granular pavement, with 55 percent not allowing recycled material, 35 percent okay with partial use and 10 percent allowing full use.Ready-mix concrete is the most restrictive use for these municipalities, with 80 percent not allowing recycled aggregate use and 20 percent allowing partial use. 

On the other side, 50 percent of municipalities are okay with recycled aggregate being used for engineered fill, and 90 percent allow partial or full use for construction access roads, bicycle paths and similar construction. 

Among individual cities, Toronto - the highest scoring municipality in the survey - allows recycled material for use in everything but engineered fill, stabilization of soft subgrades, Portland cement ready-mix, and in concrete for sidewalks, curbs and other uses within subdivisions. Some other uses are restricted, but for the most part full use is allowed. 

"I'm really pleased to see that," Bradford said. "Sometimes there's an intent to do what's right, but it doesn't get down to the foot soldiers. If we have an issue in the city of Toronto, where virgin aggregate has been called for in a tender that should have some recycled material, we'll give them a call, and they address it."On the opposite end of the spectrum is Mississauga, which allows full use of recycled aggregate only for construction access roads, bicycle paths and similar features. No recycled product is allowed for any other road construction projects.

Perception and policy
Bradford suggested that much of the disapproval of recycled materials in municipal policy may come from lingering concerns about quality - something that has improved greatly with the growth of the aggregates recycling industry. 

"You have to ensure the quality of recycled aggregate - it has to be an engineered quality, it has to be properly processed and tested. Like any material, going back 10 or 15 years there are probably a couple of things that have stuck in peoples' minds from when it was used in the infancy of the industry where it didn't work out because quality control wasn't what it should have been," Bradford said. "If you're a consultant working for a municipality, or you're an engineer in charge of the roads department, that kind of decision is a risk - so, you play it safe and just specify virgin aggregate." 

This trend of specifying new material creates many issues for contractors who have to manage the aggregate removed from jobsites, Bradford noted. 

"The owner just writes off ownership in the contract, so the contractor has to find a place to get rid of anything that comes off that project. Now, if they produce recycled aggregate themselves, they will take it to their yard and pile it up. If they don't, they have to find someone who does produce it. . . or dispose of it in the landfill," he said."The point we're reaching now is. . . there's so much of the stuff, they will have to start charging to take it in, and second they're going to have to turn people away."

Moving forwardTARBA is encouraging municipalities to find ways of using more recycled asphalt in their construction work. One example Bradford pointed to is the Ontario Ministry of Transportation, which currently uses 20 percent recycled materials in its highway construction. 

"They've been very forthcoming about their commitment to reusing recycled aggregate. . . they're using tens of millions of tons a year. If you can put this material under highways that carry the amount of traffic that ours carry, then surely there's an argument for using it under a municipal street," Bradford said. 

Only about seven percent of the aggregates used in Ontario currently come from recycled sources, as opposed to European countries which use up to 20 percent recycled product, Bradford noted. That's a goal he said TARBA would like to see municipalities aim for. 

"We are encouraging municipalities to use the Ministry of Transportation model. If municipalities have the same attitude and the same practices as the MTO, we as a province would be recycling close to the levels that we should be, and which are supportable from a technical standpoint," Bradford said. 

"There are Ontario provincial standards that look into the science behind this - what percentage of recycled aggregate you can use as a base course, or as a surface course, or on a bicycle trail. This has all been well figured out. We want municipalities to recycle the maximum allowable under the provincial specifications." RPN

This article was originally published in the January/February 2019 edition of Recycling Product News, Volume 27, Number 1.

More from Aggregates & Quarries

New Pitbull Grizzly screen an economical option for small- to mid-sized contractors

Lake Erie Portable Screeners introduces the heavy-duty Pitbull PB678 Static Grizzly. The compact screen is a smaller version of the popular PB148 for added jobsite versatility and pairs well with the Pitbull 2300 screening plant, making it an economical option for operations looking for a compact solution to sort oversize material on a reduced scale. The PB678 Static Grizzly includes features for easy bar removal or adjustments as well as transportability. It is ideal for a wide range of industries, including aggregates, mining, scrap, excavation, demolition, forestry and landscaping.

Multiple washing spreads impress at McCloskey customer open day event

Washing equipment specialist McCloskey Washing Systems (MWS), along with their UK dealer MaxInnovate Ltd, held its first multi-spread demonstration event, at Monk Plant Hire (MPH) in Hockering, Norwich, UK on Wednesday 20th and Thursday 21st March, highlighting the power of the washing equipment working together. The demonstrations were an integral part of events tailored to familiarize both new and established dealers and customers with the versatility and productivity of MWS latest products. 

Metso launches hybrid truck body with unmatched payload and wear life

"Hauling is one of the most cost-intensive components of a typical mining or quarrying operation. In addition to fuel and labor, there's plenty of maintenance involved too. To ensure cost efficiency, a haul truck should carry as much payload as possible on every round. At Metso, we set out to tackle this challenge and designed a truck body that requires minimal maintenance while maximizing payload. The result is a lower operating cost per hauled ton," says Lars Skoog, Vice President, Mining Wear Lining & Screening, Metso.

Keestrack extends worldwide manufacturing

Keestrack prides itself in consistently developing its worldwide manufacturing capacities. The company, which at bauma celebrated its 10,000th production machine since the legendary "4518" was introduced in 1996, is also marking the completion of its new 8740-square-metre assembly complex, the second extension phase of its main factory in Šternberk, Czech Republic. More milestones and new extension projects will be set and started in 2019, including the opening of Keestrack's Indian assembly in Neemrana and new production capacities in Ponzano Veneto, Italy.

free-paper-airplane

Get our newsletter

Learn more

Site planning with drones

Aggregates operators are always looking for ways to improve their efficiency and make more informed decisions in their planning processes. Many are adopting emerging technology as an added way to develop their operations, and the advent of drones is playing a large part.

Volvo CE demonstrates fully electric future for emission-free quarries

Volvo Construction Equipment's Electric Site project aims to test the world's first "emission-free" quarry by electrifying each transport stage, from excavation to primary crushing, and transport to secondary crushing. It uses both electric and autonomous Volvo CE prototype machines, plus new machine and fleet control systems and an entirely integrated real-time site management system. Together, these form a complete Electric Site solution. Volvo CE and its customer Skanska tested the viability of the Electric Site research project for 10 weeks at a Skanska's Vikan Kross quarry near Gothenburg, Sweden. Heavy Equipment Guide staff were on site to see the operation and learn about the results. 

free-magazine-subscription

Get Our Magazine

Paper or Digital delivered monthly to you

Subscribe or Renew Learn more

ROCKSTER to present most powerful, low-emission mobile impact crusher at bauma 2019

Since its founding in 2004, ROCKSTER has developed two patented systems for mobile crushers. At bauma 2019, the mobile impact crusher R1100DS will be displayed in the open area in front of the B2 Hall / Gate 7 (Booth No. 12B/2). The machine combines both innovative systems (DUPLEX and double-functional return / stockpile belt) and as of 2019, it will be equipped with a CAT C9.3B EUR5 engine. This will offer customers the latest state-of-the-art technology.

Telsmith 3244 portable crusher delivers a mobile advantage

The Telsmith 3244 Portable Plant provides the portable crushing producer consistent, reliable production, low mobilization costs, and the flexibility in a number of processing applications such as producing quarried stone, sand and gravel, and recycling. The 3244 primary jaw plant can be used alone or configured with other mobile plants to create a complete processing system in aggregates processing.

Powerscreen of Canada to show latest crushing and screening plants at National Heavy Equipment Show

Powerscreen is one of the world's leading providers of mobile crushing, screening and conveying equipment. Official distributors, Powerscreen of Canada will exhibit at the National Heavy Equipment Show in Toronto, from March 28-29th, 2019. Exhibiting at booth number 5004, experts will be on hand to talk crushing and screening and visitors will have the opportunity to get up close to a Powerscreen Chieftain 2200 screen.

free-paper-airplane

Get our newsletter

Learn more

Bridgestone brings portfolio of OTR tire solutions to AGG1

Bridgestone Americas, Inc. will exhibit its integrated portfolio of off-the-road (OTR) products, technologies and services at the National Stone, Sand and Gravel Association Aggregates Academy and Expo (AGG1) and World of Asphalt 2019 Show and Conference, Feb. 12-14 in Indianapolis, Indiana. Located at booth 31089, Bridgestone will showcase the benefits of using products backed by integrated technologies to drive increased productivity for customers.

New sidewall protection for OTR tires designed for concrete and aggregates recycling

At concrete and aggregate recycling sites, recycled aggregate is produced by crushing concrete and asphalt to reuse the aggregate in the construction industry as a base for roads or building foundations.  To keep operations running site managers rely on loaders to push large jagged chunks of torn up sidewalk, roadway or building materials - which can contain steel rebar - to the crushing line to reduce its size.

Metso to expand NW Rapid crushing plant range

Metso is introducing new higher capacity models to its popular wheel-mounted Metso NW Rapid series. In addition to a bigger jaw crusher model, the NW Rapid units are now also available with a variety of robust cone crushers, including the first model with the MX crusher. Easily transportable using standard prime movers, over a thousand NW Rapid models have already been sold into aggregates and C&D recycling applications.

free-magazine-subscription

Get Our Magazine

Paper or Digital delivered monthly to you

Subscribe or Renew Learn more